đ„âTHE KING WHO NEVER WAS: How Sam Heughan Came Within a Swordâs Reach of Game of Thrones GloryâSeven Timesâđ„
đ„âTHE KING WHO NEVER WAS: How Sam Heughan Came Within a Swordâs Reach of Game of Thrones GloryâSeven Timesâđ„
Before he became Outlanderâs brooding Highland warrior and global heartthrob, Sam Heughan was swinging at another kind of crown â one forged in dragons, politics, and blood. Yes, the Scottish star once came this close to ruling Westeros.
In a revelation that stunned fans and delighted trivia lovers alike, Heughan recently admitted that before he became Jamie Fraser, he auditioned not once, not twice, but seven times for Game of Thrones. And not for minor parts, either â he was in the running for some of the seriesâ most memorable characters, including Renly Baratheon, Loras Tyrell, and several members of the Nightâs Watch.
âI auditioned for Game of Thrones seven times! Loads of times,â Heughan told Vulture with a laugh. âI auditioned for Renly, Loras, some of the members of the Nightâs Watch. And Iâd always get so close! Iâd be like, âGuys, just give me a sword!â Everyone was going in for those parts.â
Imagine it: a world where Outlanderâs Jamie Fraser might never have existed â because Sam Heughan wouldâve been too busy plotting from Kingâs Landing or freezing on the Wall beside Jon Snow.
THE KING WHO ALMOST WAS
Back in the early 2010s, Game of Thrones was the golden ticket every British actor wanted to punch. From Kit Harington to Emilia Clarke, the fantasy epic became an overnight launchpad for new faces and careers. And Heughan, then a rising stage actor in London, was right in the thick of it.
He didnât just read for one role. He came back again and again, each time making it to the final round â each time hearing that agonizing phrase no actor wants: âYou were so close.â
The most painful near miss? The role of Renly Baratheon, the charming, ambitious brother of King Robert â a man whose gentle charisma and tragic fate became one of the seriesâ most poignant early arcs. The part eventually went to Gethin Anthony, but Heughanâs name was on the shortlist until the very end.
âIâd always get so close,â Heughan said, still laughing about it years later. âJust give me a sword!â
Itâs easy to see why HBOâs casting team kept calling him back. Even before Outlander, Heughan had that blend of physical strength and soulful gravitas that makes audiences lean forward. He couldâve been a Baratheon. He couldâve been a knight of the Reach. He couldâve stood on the Wall, black cloak billowing, beside Jon Snow.
But fate â and perhaps a time-traveling stone circle â had other plans.
FROM REJECTION TO REDEMPTION
Rejection can crush an actor. But for Sam Heughan, each Game of Thrones audition became a lesson â a training ground for something bigger.
âItâs funny about those things,â he reflected. âYouâre up for so many roles. Coming from those auditions, and testing on other shows, I had more experience with the process. Maybe I was more confident. And I donât know â something about Outlander just felt right. This part felt different. I knew this character. I felt a connection with him.â
That connection changed everything.
In 2014, Outlander premiered on Starz, introducing the world to Jamie Fraser â the dashing Scottish warrior whose honor, tenderness, and quiet fire captivated millions. The show opened to strong numbers: 2.3 million viewers on premiere night, with another 1.4 million tuning in across platforms, breaking records for the network.
Almost overnight, Sam Heughan went from âthat actor who almost made it on Game of Thronesâ to an international phenomenon. His portrayal of Jamie didnât just win him awards â it inspired legions of fans, from the fiercely devoted âHeughligansâ to historians drawn to the showâs authentic Highland roots.
WHAT IF HE HAD WON THE IRON THRONE?
Itâs a tantalizing question: what if Sam Heughan had been cast on Game of Thrones?
Would he have stolen the spotlight from Kit Harington as Jon Snow?
Would Renly Baratheonâs tragic arc have struck an even deeper chord with Heughanâs gravitas?
Or would he have been lost amid the massive ensemble, his charisma buried under armor and CGI dragons?
Weâll never know â but perhaps itâs better this way. Because in Outlander, Heughan found something Game of Thrones could never offer: a single role that demanded every layer of his talent.
Jamie Fraser isnât just a warrior; heâs a lover, a leader, a husband, a man shaped by centuries. Itâs a performance that requires both brute strength and delicate emotional range â qualities Heughan has in spades.
THE IRONIES OF CASTING DESTINY
The entertainment industry is full of what-ifs, but Heughanâs story has become one of Hollywoodâs favorite âmissed-it-by-that-muchâ legends. Itâs poetic, really: he didnât become Renly Baratheon, the would-be king, but he did become another kind of king â one ruling hearts across continents.
Even the Outlander team had its own wild what-if moments. In one of the showâs early casting considerations, both Liam Neeson and Sean Connery were once floated for the role of Jamie Fraser. Imagine that version of Outlander!
But destiny circled back to Heughan. And maybe, after all those Game of Thrones auditions, the universe owed him something epic.
SEVEN AUDITIONS, ONE DESTINY
For Heughan, every near miss became a rehearsal for the role that would define his career. The swords, the Scottish accent, the stoicism â everything he honed for Thrones found its home in Outlander.
He didnât need the Iron Throne. He built his own.
Today, as Outlander continues to expand its global fanbase, Heughanâs journey serves as both an inspiration and a reminder: sometimes, the doors that close are the ones that guide you exactly where you belong.
âI think I was meant to play Jamie,â Heughan once said. âWhen I first read him, I knew who he was. I didnât have to think â I just felt it.â
So yes, Sam Heughan couldâve been king of the Seven Kingdoms.
But instead, he became something rarer â the King of Hearts for millions of fans who canât imagine another man wielding that sword, speaking in that voice, or loving Claire Fraser across centuries.
And for that, we can all be thankful that the Game of Thrones casting team â seven times over â said no.
Because fate was quietly whispering:
Not this throne. His throne awaits in the Highlands.